The wet-dry flip-flop

Three summers ago, the north of New Zealand was in drought while Southland suffered floods. This summer, we’ve got the inverse. What’s going on?

Feb 15, 2023

Kia ora, welcome to Future Proof brought to you by Electric Kiwi.

I hope you’re staying safe and dry. The last few days have been harrowing for many across the North Island. My thoughts are with those affected by the cyclone. Huge mihi to all the first responders.

Drought in Northland, 2020 (Image: RNZ) / Flooding in Wairoa, February 2023 (Image: Hawke's Bay Civil Defence)

With the north drenched to its core by so much rain, it’s easy to forget that just a couple of summers ago we were in the midst of a drought. Aucklanders were being urged to conserve water as dam supplies dwindled and Northland farmers were forced to cull stock. Meanwhile, Southland was ravaged by floods and landslides.

This summer, the situation is inverted, with dry heat in the south and way too much wet in the north. Data journalist Chris McDowall wondered what was behind this wet-dry flip-flop. So I asked Sam Dean, NIWA climate scientist.

‘Blocking high’ behind north-south pattern

The “north-south dipole” is a pattern that’s often seen in New Zealand, says Dean. “When you analyse rainfall, it’s one of the primary patterns that comes out — but it’s not the only pattern. Just because it’s wet in the north doesn’t guarantee it’s dry in the south.”

Dean explains that behind this flip-flop, a bunch of large scale systems align to create “blocking highs” — including the depletion of the ozone layer, which has shifted regular storms poleward, encouraging highs to form above New Zealand. Exactly where these high pressure systems sit determines who gets wet, and who stays dry. This year, the forces of La Niña and other regional climate cycles have led to a blocking high off the east, which has opened the door for rainfall-bearing systems like the ex-tropical cyclone to bear down on the north. “The cyclone is being affected by this high pressure east of the country: it’s got nowhere to go, and has become very slow moving. This increases the damage because it goes on for longer, rather than nipping by,” says Dean.

Will we see more cyclones as the climate changes?

On average, we see one ex-tropical cyclone pass close to New Zealand every summer, and Dean says we don’t have any evidence that this number will increase. But as the climate warms, “there’s more fuel for them when they do happen — more heat, more moisture — so they can have stronger winds and more intense rainfall.”

Averages mask the extremes

Back in 2020, The Spinoff published The 100 Year Forecast, a video series examining Aotearoa’s climate future. Looking at the seasonal maps, you can see which regions will get wetter or drier on average. But what these seasonal averages mask are the extreme events that will define our climate future; the flip-flops between drought and downpours. “Models suggest that short duration flash flooding — like we saw in Auckland in January — is going to increase the most under climate change,” says Dean. “Also, Northland and Auckland will see the biggest increases. That part of the country is becoming distinctly more variable.”

While the models predict that severe rainfall will become more intense and more frequent, the “off-the-charts” events like Auckland’s floods pose a challenge for scientists when it comes to understanding how they form, and how they’re affected by climate change. “We are embarking on a crazy experiment, fundamentally terraforming the planet into a different kind of place. And there are massive risks associated with that,” says Dean. “We don’t necessarily have a good understanding of how some of these most extreme events are going to behave when you give them that much more energy to work with.”

While such extremes are scary, Dean emphasises that New Zealand will always be relatively habitable compared to many places around the world. “As long as things aren’t changing too fast, then people are really adaptive,” he says. “The more we can slow the changing climate, the better chance we have to adapt.”

And for those impacted by the current devastation: “I just hope for those people that they can rebuild their lives and find a way to be safe in a changing climate.”

The Spinoff's independent, homegrown journalism is only possible because of the support of our members. Their generous donations power all our work and help keep it freely available to all. Tautoko The Spinoff this year by becoming a member, making a new donation or encouraging your organisation to donate.

New Zealanders aren’t so keen on climate action, actually

A new poll, conducted just after the January 27 floods in Auckland, finds that New Zealanders are less likely than most others to want actions that would reduce their carbon emissions. Bernard Hickey dives into the details of the survey results for his newsletter The Kākā, republished on The Spinoff here.

Houses and floods

There’s been a bit of talk about “houses where they shouldn’t be”: Hayden Donnell takes a good hard look at the housing policies that preceded the Auckland floods on The Spinoff and Stuff’s Olivia Wannan explains a delayed law that could allow flood-hit homeowners to sell their homes to the government and move elsewhere.

Earth has lost more than 20% of wetlands since 1700

Earth may have lost about one-fifth of its wetlands, according to a new analysis, but this is much lower than the previous best guess of 50% lost. In New Zealand, the relative destruction is much greater, with the oft-cited figure of 90% of wetlands lost since European colonisation. It’s a shocking stat, but we have a chance to turn it around: an analysis by Forest & Bird for World Wetland Day identified around 125,000 hectares of former wetland on public land that could be restored to its former boggy glory.

Biofuel mandate binned, leaving carbon budgets unbalanced

As part of his policy purge last week, prime minister Chris Hipkins binned the biofuel mandate, which would have required petrol and diesel to contain a proportion of fuel from biological sources, starting in April 2024. The axing of this policy leaves a sizable hole in New Zealand’s carbon budgets — up to 10 million tonnes’ worth of emissions – and it’s unclear how the government will plug the glaring gap. Newsroom’s Marc Daalder has a good analysis of the decision and its implications.